Em Colley
  • Home
  • Homeopathy
    • Are we a fit?
    • Availability/Fees
    • Homeopathy - what can it treat?
    • The Homeopathic Consultation - what's it like to work with me?
    • How to take a remedy
    • I believe...
    • Testimonials
    • Homeopathy Awareness Week
    • Homeopathy and Wikipedia
  • The Joy of Homeopathy
    • TJOH Wall of Fame
  • Supervision
    • Supervision Matters Course >
      • Supervisors
  • Me
    • As a Speaker
    • Food >
      • Food Intolerance Testing
      • Testimonials
      • Recipes >
        • Breakfast Ideas >
          • Banana Boats
          • Breakfast ice cream on fresh fruit
          • Granola
          • Smoothie bowl
          • Sunrise Smoothie Bowl
        • Dips, Dressings & Appetisers >
          • Carrot, Orange and Ginger Soup
          • Cheese-less cheese dip
          • Guacamole
          • Hummus (oil free)
          • Mango and Cucumber Dressing
          • Ranch Dressing
          • Seedy 'Slaw
          • Summer salad dressing
          • Wild Garlic Pesto
        • Mains >
          • Cashew Cheese-y Kale Salad
          • Creamy Avocado Noodles
          • Green Mango Soup
          • Lasagne. Scrummy, yummy, vegan lasagne.
          • Mango Spinach Salad
          • Middle Eastern Inspired Dinner
          • Moroccan Inspired Salad Dressing
          • Raw Coconut Curry with Cauliflower 'Rice'
          • Raw Curry
          • Simple, Tasty and Nutritious Romaine Wraps
          • Spiralised courgette, chopped tomatoes, celery, spring onion with an red pepper, garlic, lemon and cashew cream sauce
          • Squashy Mac n Cheese
          • Sundried Tomato Tart
          • Sweet Mango Noodles
          • Sweet and Sour Noodles
          • Sweet potato, chilli mixed veg with cauliflower and kale 'rice'
          • Vegan Carbonara with Vegetables
        • Desserts >
          • Almond butter and date toffee stacks
          • Anyone for (low fat, high carb, raw vegan) Blueberry Pie?
          • Apple and strawberry crumble with salted caramel nice cream
          • Banoffee Ice Cream Pie
          • Banoffee Pecan Pie
          • Birthday cake pie!
          • Carrot Cake Balls
          • Chocolate almond sundae
          • Chocolate and Peanut Butter Pudding
          • Chocolate Extravaganza Ice Cream
          • Chocolate Ginger Brownies
          • Chocolate Orange Cupcakes with Raw Chocolate Icing
          • Chocolate orange fudge
          • Christmas Energy Balls
          • Christmas pudding 'cheesecake'
          • Cinnamon, vanilla pud
          • Coconut Happy Bars
          • Ice Cream Cake
          • Lime Cheesecake
          • Mango and apple tart
          • Mango and Raspberry Tart
          • PBJ Ice Cream
          • Peanut Butter Banoffee Pots
          • Peanut Butter Bar
          • Pecan Date Bites
          • Plant power pancakes
          • Pumpkin Pie (raw vegan)
          • Raw Bilberry Pie
          • Raw Chocolate
          • Raw Chocolate Brownies
          • Raw Coconut and Sultana Brownies
          • Raw Energy Balls
          • Raw Ice Cream
          • Raw Raspberry Cheesecake
          • Raw Rolos
          • Raw Snickers Joy
          • Rocky Road Raw Vegan Style
          • Salted Caramel Almond Nice Cream
          • Summer Fruit Nice Cream with Mango Sorbet and Fruit Coulis
          • Super Cookies
          • Vegan chocolate chip cookies
        • Smoothies and Juices >
          • Banana Free Smoothies
          • Caramel chocolate smoothie
          • Juices
          • Smoothies (featuring the brilliant banana)
    • Laughter Yoga >
      • Laughter Yoga feedback
      • Laughter Yoga Sessions
      • Laughter Yoga Exercises
    • Leonie Dawson courses
    • Mindfulness >
      • My Children's Meditations
    • Things I love
  • Get in touch
  • Events
    • Current Events
    • Past Events >
      • A Plank a Day for HHA
      • ARH Conference
      • The Ceilidh at Christmas 2024
      • Ceilidh at Christmas 2022
      • Ceilidh at Christmas 2023
      • Homeopathy Marathon
      • Introduction to Homeopathy
      • Inspired by Homeopathy
      • Retreat
      • Shamanic Ceremony
      • The Compassion Sessions
      • The Happiness Sessions
  • Shop
    • Cotton Bags
    • Curiosity mugs
    • Homeopath mugs
    • Play out posters and postcards
    • Soul of a Mugs
    • T-shirts
  • Blog
07734 861297

Thoughts on the world, homeopathy, mindfulness and food...

A collection of blog posts - feel free to respond with your thoughts and comments - I love to have feedback - thank you!

My view of The Times view of homeopaths...

4/13/2020

6 Comments

 
The Times view of homeopaths promoting bogus coronavirus treatments: Junk Medicine

"British homeopaths are promoting bogus treatments for the coronavirus" they say...
Monday April 13 2020, 12.01am, The Times

If you've been with me for a while, this is following the same pattern as previous blogs based on newspaper "fiction". The article is posted below, with relevant points I feel are worth exploring which will be in italics. I will include links to discover more, should you be interested to do so.

Picture

The number of recorded deaths of hospital patients in this country with Covid-19 now exceeds 10,000. Sir Jeremy Farrar, director of the Wellcome Trust and a government adviser on the pandemic, warned yesterday that Britain was likely to be among the worst-affected countries, if not the worst of all, in Europe. In a public health crisis of such severity it is a natural human impulse to seek protection against infection. We report today that hundreds of homeopathic practitioners across the country are promoting treatments that purportedly provide it.

No. No they are not. Hundreds of practitioners are not doing this. Having worked with, studied with and got to know so many homeopaths - no one I know is talking about protection against infection. I do know people are talking about giving remedies that might help people be healthier though - that's what we do. I did also hear that in Cuba there are a group using homeopathic medicines as potential prophylaxis for the virus. They follow a history of successfully using homeopathy to deal with potential epidemics in the country which is particularly interesting and perhaps a story The Times might like to report on. Conclusions of a study, working with leptospirosis that was reported in 2010 stated: "The homeoprophylactic approach was associated with a large reduction of disease incidence and control of the epidemic." Interesting indeed.

More interesting yet (for me at least) are the facts that it wasn't conducted by homeopaths, it was scientifically robust, and had the results they gained come from the conventional scientific world, they would have been shouted from the rooftops. Did you hear about it? If you're reading this from outside of the homeopathic community the chances are you didn't. Were they able to publish in any of the medical journals they set it to, despite having been published before? No. Why might that be? Not that it wasn't a successful, interesting study. If you're curious, the excellent documentary film Magic Pills explores it further. And also talks about the other diseases that the Cubans successfully used homeoprophylaxis for. It's $4.99 to download - and a perfect time to find out more about it - addressing many of the issues raised in the media recently around homeopathy, looking at both sides of the argument.

Picture

Their claims are bogus. The basis for them is not medical science but superstition and wishful thinking. The practitioners who provide these supposed remedies are instilling false hope, profiting from vulnerability, and putting lives at risk. Their activity is exploitative and unethical, and it needs to be shut down straightaway.

Homeopathy is medical science, and fortunately in many places it is treated as such. Instilling false hope? For a start, I'd be intrigued, I am intrigued by the idea of false hope. If we were to step aside from the homeopathy issue for a moment and think about hope instead of fear, think about the placebo effect instead of the nocebo effect, think about those stories - you must have heard them too. You know the ones, where a patient is given the wrong diagnosis and they follow the anticipated path of disease and subsequent death. The other was so very ill, told they were well and recover. you know that one? I suppose the message is it works out like that because the placebo effect is very strong. Continuing to take homeopathy out of it, if 30% of people can recover due to placebo which I've seen suggested elsewhere, then hope feels to me to be an important part of the picture. Streaming constant fear into our living rooms feels to be criminal. This feels to me to be putting lives at risk. I'm well known to rant about this one to friends and family, so will kick away my soap box before I get started there. 

Covid-19 is an infectious disease caused by a coronavirus that was unknown before December. There is no cure for it. Scientists are working at breakneck pace to develop a vaccine. The notion that the highly diluted substances that homeopaths describe as remedies may offer protection from this threat will appear, to most people, intuitively implausible.

I don't want to get too far off point, but having heard many contradictory reports to it being unknown before December, having heard that the virus genome analysis looks like it was around from September 2019, I find it difficult to believe it was unknown before December. To be honest there are many viruses that are unknown to most of the public all the time. This one has attracted untold media attention and I doubt it's unknown to anyone now.

Yes there is no cure for it. As with the common cold, as with 'flu. As with so many things. All the more reason to boost our own immune system and get excited about the things we can do to be healthier. Which I've seen pretty much nowhere in mainstream media. Again, not so helpful. Wash your hands. Is that the best we've got? "Breakneck pace to develop a vaccine" sounds all very well - however to my awareness coronavirus vaccines are notoriously difficult to develop and have been previously attempted and abandoned. So we wait and see. 


Yet our investigation using a database developed by the Good Thinking Society, a pro-science charity, reveals that British homeopaths are promoting herbal concoctions as a counter to Covid-19. One homeopath based in London is charging new patients £150 an hour for his “Coronavirus Remote Consulting” service, with an additional £20 monthly fee for sending prescription treatments from pharmacies.

For a start, homeopaths, unless they're also herbalists, are very unlikely to be promoting herbal concoctions. This rings warning bells for me in the accuracy of reporting to begin with. And if they are, then we're talking about herbal medicines not homeopathy, rendering the references to homeopathy in the article quite pointless.

The euphemism for this sort of ministering to the sick and vulnerable is complementary medicine, but it would be more accurate to refer to it as pseudoscience. And it has always been this way. Homeopathy was dreamt up by a German physician called Samuel Hahnemann in the 1790s. Its premise is that a patient can be cured of a malady by administering a drug or substance in so heavily diluted a form, either in water or alcohol, that sometimes not even a molecule of the original substance remains.

Dreamt up. A great phrase. Brilliant put down really. It discounts years and years of hard work, refining, countless case books, hundreds of happy patients, including many of the rich and famous of the times. Recoveries from illnesses that conventional medicine had no answers for.. It discounts millions of people using homeopathy around the world. It discounts thousands of practitioners working everyday with health and so much more. If you get the opportunity to read some of the old texts around homeopathy, Dr Elizabeth Hubbard for example. Totally inspirational. Also have a read of Rima Handley's A Homeopathic Love Story for a brilliant scene setting of where homeopathy came out of, but also the passion, the incredible work and amazing results. Dreamt up. In your dreams The Times.

It seems that the authors of the article have not heard of nanotechnology, nano medicines? Not just a euphemism for homeopathy, nano-medicines are something the conventional world are getting excited about, approved by the FDA since 1995. More on that here. And, do you know what? There is evidence to suggest this may be one way homeopathy may work too. Interesting. If you'd like to read about that more, here you go, or if you're more of a watcher, you might like the clip below from the film Magic Pills, mentioned earlier.


If you're intrigued by Professor Bellare, I was lucky enough to hear him talk at a conference several summers ago. There's more here if you'd like to explore the nano-medicine idea further. 

​There is no evidence that homeopathy is effective. A report by the House of Commons select committee on science and technology in 2010 concluded that homeopathic treatments performed no better than placebos, or dummy medicine, and that the principles on which they were based were scientifically implausible.

Oh my word. That old chestnut. "No evidence that homeopathy is effective". Wow. That anyone can still print that amazes me. There are years of evidence that it is effective. There are case notes on top of case notes. There are trials. There is a growing bank of evidence, and it's hugely exciting. The 2010 report and how it was carried out is shocking by the way, once you really start to look into it. You might like to find out more here. Whilst I'm here, The Australian Review, the most recent, and particularly damning review which echoed around the world, feels to be shrouded in mystery. The first review was abandoned, a new team was formed and the second review found that homeopathy was not effective in helping any medical condition. Particularly alarming now, given that recent investigations have discovered that “Contrary to some claims, the [first] review did not conclude that homeopathy was ineffective.” Read more here. More on the background of the Australian Review issues here. 

In fact, whilst we're still on the topic of lack of evidence, and the author is about to move onto the Royal Family patronage, here's Dr Peter Fisher on that one. Dr Fisher was homeopath to The Queen until his recent death and speaks clearly about some of the issues involved here..



The supposed discipline of homeopathy retains its place in public life not because scientific researchers see a place for it but, in part at least, because it enjoys high-profile patronage. The Prince of Wales has urged that “science and homeopathy must work in harmony”, which is a bit like calling for an alliance of locksmiths and burglars.

Err... yes they do. Plenty of scientists, despite there being no glamour, no huge accolade, and plenty of stick to be taken, are intrigued, fascinated and very involved in homeopathy. Nice analogy, but no. I saw this clip doing the rounds today and feels so super relevant I wanted to share it here. Says it beautifully. Also "there is no scientific evidence homeopathy works" - wrong. Have a read here. And if you didn't watch Dr Peter Fisher a moment ago, do have a look at the short film above.

The Society of Homeopaths, even so, maintains the trappings of a professional organisation and keeps a register of accredited members. It reports to an independent regulatory organisation, the Professional Standards Authority for Health and Social Care, which is responsible for protecting the public. In a global pandemic that has infected more than 1.8 million people and shut down the world economy, false hope is seductive and deadly. British homeopaths are spreading it, and they must be held accountable.

I would argue that the media is spreading terror, and they should be held accountable. False hope from homeopaths? For a start homeopathy is far more efficacious than this article would have you know, and for seconds British homeopaths are a tiny, tiny group. If they are able to spread anything around the world then perhaps they and the medicine they are using is far more powerful than The Times, and the Good Thinking Society, who appear to be behind this article, would like us to know.
​​​
6 Comments
Lorraine link
4/14/2020 01:17:10 am

Wonderful. Great counter explanation beautifully done. Thank you Em x

Reply
Iris Hay link
4/14/2020 02:22:28 am

Many thanks Emma for this great article that sums it all up - I hope people will take time to investigate things further with the links you provided.

Reply
Anne Sash link
4/14/2020 03:44:18 am

Great article, thanks Em!
How pathetic, these reporters who just can't fact find for themselves, relying lazily upon skeptic cultists for their stories. And that's what they are. Stories. Fiction. Poorly written. As you say, there IS some REAL news to be reported, if they could just drag themselves out of the gutter for a while.

Reply
Reeta Pohjonen link
4/14/2020 07:07:12 am

Great article. Will share it with my school students and on my wall.
Thank you for putting it all together, Em :)

Reply
Lisa link
4/14/2020 07:07:44 am

Thank you Emma for taking the time and trouble to counter this particularly spurious piece of fiction from Stoneman. If you look at his track record, he certainly has a few pet subjects. Here's a list: https://muckrack.com/justin-stoneman/articles
As Sun Tzu said in The Art of War, 'Know your enemy...'

Reply
Dee Morris
4/14/2020 03:27:14 pm

Excellent piece, dispatching as it did, the same wearying, tedious old shibboleths constantly trotted our about Homeopathy. I particularly like the idea of the media now being held accountable for their appalling, conscienceless fear mongering in order to sell more newspapers. That’s REALLY principled.

Dee

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    I'm a Homeopath working in the Skipton (North Yorkshire) area. I am also able to offer food intolerance testing using Kinesiology and advice around diet and lifestyle.
    My blog is a reflection of thoughts, collection of recipes, suggestions of self help remedies and more.

    Archives

    February 2025
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    January 2020
    July 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013

    Categories

    All
    2014 Calendar
    Absolute Specialists
    Animals
    Apple
    Avocado
    Ayuvedic Medicine
    Banana
    Banana Free
    Bowen
    Breakfast
    Byron Katie
    Cancer
    Carrot
    Challenge
    Change
    Charity
    Chocolate
    Coconut Oil
    Dairy Free
    Dates
    Date Toffee
    Diabetes
    Diet
    Dynamis
    Epidemic
    Exercise
    Fish
    Focussed Mindfulness
    Food Production
    Food Production
    Forks Over Knives
    Gerson
    Green Smoothie
    Hayfever
    Headache
    Health
    Healthy
    Holiday
    Homeopathy
    Homeopathy For Health In Africa
    Homeopathy For Health In Africa
    Homeopathyhour
    Homeopathy Research
    Homeopathy Worked For Me
    Horse
    Ice Cream
    Ilkley
    International Diabetes Federation
    Juice
    Juicing
    Kale
    Kuvings Juicer
    Love
    Make A Difference
    Mango
    Migraine
    Milk
    Mindfulness
    Mouth
    Naked
    Neal Bernard
    Ngo
    Nutrition
    Oil Pulling
    Oral Hygiene
    Orange
    Peach
    Philips Juicer
    Pineapple
    Protein
    Pudding
    Raw Chocolate
    Raw Food
    Raw Food
    Raw Ice Cream
    Remedies
    Remedy
    Research
    Running
    Russell Brand
    Santa Fun Run
    Selfies
    Skipton
    Smoothie
    Spinach
    Strawberry
    Studio Pilates
    Studio Pilates
    Sundae
    Sustainability
    Talks
    Teeth
    The China Study
    The Snooks
    Treat
    Tumeric
    Vegan
    Vegan Smythe
    Vegetarian
    Water Fasting
    Water Fasting
    Watermelon
    Weight Gain
    Weight Loss
    Weight Loss
    World Aids Day
    World Diabetes Day
    Youtube

    RSS Feed

07734 861297   
[email protected]


Em Colley Homeopath
Practitioner of Classical Homeopathy
BSc(Hons) Psychology and Neuroscience
Laughter Yoga Leader
Focussed Mindfulness Practitioner

Picture
Picture
www.findahomeopath.org
Member of the
Alliance of
Registered Homeopaths
  • Home
  • Homeopathy
    • Are we a fit?
    • Availability/Fees
    • Homeopathy - what can it treat?
    • The Homeopathic Consultation - what's it like to work with me?
    • How to take a remedy
    • I believe...
    • Testimonials
    • Homeopathy Awareness Week
    • Homeopathy and Wikipedia
  • The Joy of Homeopathy
    • TJOH Wall of Fame
  • Supervision
    • Supervision Matters Course >
      • Supervisors
  • Me
    • As a Speaker
    • Food >
      • Food Intolerance Testing
      • Testimonials
      • Recipes >
        • Breakfast Ideas >
          • Banana Boats
          • Breakfast ice cream on fresh fruit
          • Granola
          • Smoothie bowl
          • Sunrise Smoothie Bowl
        • Dips, Dressings & Appetisers >
          • Carrot, Orange and Ginger Soup
          • Cheese-less cheese dip
          • Guacamole
          • Hummus (oil free)
          • Mango and Cucumber Dressing
          • Ranch Dressing
          • Seedy 'Slaw
          • Summer salad dressing
          • Wild Garlic Pesto
        • Mains >
          • Cashew Cheese-y Kale Salad
          • Creamy Avocado Noodles
          • Green Mango Soup
          • Lasagne. Scrummy, yummy, vegan lasagne.
          • Mango Spinach Salad
          • Middle Eastern Inspired Dinner
          • Moroccan Inspired Salad Dressing
          • Raw Coconut Curry with Cauliflower 'Rice'
          • Raw Curry
          • Simple, Tasty and Nutritious Romaine Wraps
          • Spiralised courgette, chopped tomatoes, celery, spring onion with an red pepper, garlic, lemon and cashew cream sauce
          • Squashy Mac n Cheese
          • Sundried Tomato Tart
          • Sweet Mango Noodles
          • Sweet and Sour Noodles
          • Sweet potato, chilli mixed veg with cauliflower and kale 'rice'
          • Vegan Carbonara with Vegetables
        • Desserts >
          • Almond butter and date toffee stacks
          • Anyone for (low fat, high carb, raw vegan) Blueberry Pie?
          • Apple and strawberry crumble with salted caramel nice cream
          • Banoffee Ice Cream Pie
          • Banoffee Pecan Pie
          • Birthday cake pie!
          • Carrot Cake Balls
          • Chocolate almond sundae
          • Chocolate and Peanut Butter Pudding
          • Chocolate Extravaganza Ice Cream
          • Chocolate Ginger Brownies
          • Chocolate Orange Cupcakes with Raw Chocolate Icing
          • Chocolate orange fudge
          • Christmas Energy Balls
          • Christmas pudding 'cheesecake'
          • Cinnamon, vanilla pud
          • Coconut Happy Bars
          • Ice Cream Cake
          • Lime Cheesecake
          • Mango and apple tart
          • Mango and Raspberry Tart
          • PBJ Ice Cream
          • Peanut Butter Banoffee Pots
          • Peanut Butter Bar
          • Pecan Date Bites
          • Plant power pancakes
          • Pumpkin Pie (raw vegan)
          • Raw Bilberry Pie
          • Raw Chocolate
          • Raw Chocolate Brownies
          • Raw Coconut and Sultana Brownies
          • Raw Energy Balls
          • Raw Ice Cream
          • Raw Raspberry Cheesecake
          • Raw Rolos
          • Raw Snickers Joy
          • Rocky Road Raw Vegan Style
          • Salted Caramel Almond Nice Cream
          • Summer Fruit Nice Cream with Mango Sorbet and Fruit Coulis
          • Super Cookies
          • Vegan chocolate chip cookies
        • Smoothies and Juices >
          • Banana Free Smoothies
          • Caramel chocolate smoothie
          • Juices
          • Smoothies (featuring the brilliant banana)
    • Laughter Yoga >
      • Laughter Yoga feedback
      • Laughter Yoga Sessions
      • Laughter Yoga Exercises
    • Leonie Dawson courses
    • Mindfulness >
      • My Children's Meditations
    • Things I love
  • Get in touch
  • Events
    • Current Events
    • Past Events >
      • A Plank a Day for HHA
      • ARH Conference
      • The Ceilidh at Christmas 2024
      • Ceilidh at Christmas 2022
      • Ceilidh at Christmas 2023
      • Homeopathy Marathon
      • Introduction to Homeopathy
      • Inspired by Homeopathy
      • Retreat
      • Shamanic Ceremony
      • The Compassion Sessions
      • The Happiness Sessions
  • Shop
    • Cotton Bags
    • Curiosity mugs
    • Homeopath mugs
    • Play out posters and postcards
    • Soul of a Mugs
    • T-shirts
  • Blog