Em Colley
  • Home
  • Homeopathy
    • Homeopathy - what can it treat?
    • The Homeopathic Consultation - what should I expect?
    • Testimonials
    • How to take a remedy
    • Homeopathy Awareness Week
    • Homeopathy and Wikipedia
  • Laughter Yoga
    • Laughter Yoga feedback
    • Laughter Yoga Sessions
    • Laughter Yoga Exercises
  • Supervision
  • Food
    • Food Intolerance Testing
    • Testimonials
    • Recipes >
      • Breakfast Ideas >
        • Banana Boats
        • Breakfast ice cream on fresh fruit
        • Granola
        • Smoothie bowl
        • Sunrise Smoothie Bowl
      • Dips, Dressings & Appetisers >
        • Carrot, Orange and Ginger Soup
        • Cheese-less cheese dip
        • Guacamole
        • Hummus (oil free)
        • Mango and Cucumber Dressing
        • Ranch Dressing
        • Seedy 'Slaw
        • Summer salad dressing
        • Wild Garlic Pesto
      • Mains >
        • Cashew Cheese-y Kale Salad
        • Creamy Avocado Noodles
        • Green Mango Soup
        • Lasagne. Scrummy, yummy, vegan lasagne.
        • Mango Spinach Salad
        • Middle Eastern Inspired Dinner
        • Moroccan Inspired Salad Dressing
        • Raw Coconut Curry with Cauliflower 'Rice'
        • Raw Curry
        • Simple, Tasty and Nutritious Romaine Wraps
        • Spiralised courgette, chopped tomatoes, celery, spring onion with an red pepper, garlic, lemon and cashew cream sauce
        • Squashy Mac n Cheese
        • Sundried Tomato Tart
        • Sweet Mango Noodles
        • Sweet and Sour Noodles
        • Sweet potato, chilli mixed veg with cauliflower and kale 'rice'
        • Vegan Carbonara with Vegetables
      • Desserts >
        • Almond butter and date toffee stacks
        • Anyone for (low fat, high carb, raw vegan) Blueberry Pie?
        • Apple and strawberry crumble with salted caramel nice cream
        • Banoffee Ice Cream Pie
        • Banoffee Pecan Pie
        • Birthday cake pie!
        • Carrot Cake Balls
        • Chocolate almond sundae
        • Chocolate and Peanut Butter Pudding
        • Chocolate Extravaganza Ice Cream
        • Chocolate Ginger Brownies
        • Chocolate Orange Cupcakes with Raw Chocolate Icing
        • Chocolate orange fudge
        • Christmas Energy Balls
        • Christmas pudding 'cheesecake'
        • Cinnamon, vanilla pud
        • Coconut Happy Bars
        • Ice Cream Cake
        • Lime Cheesecake
        • Mango and apple tart
        • Mango and Raspberry Tart
        • PBJ Ice Cream
        • Peanut Butter Banoffee Pots
        • Peanut Butter Bar
        • Pecan Date Bites
        • Plant power pancakes
        • Pumpkin Pie (raw vegan)
        • Raw Bilberry Pie
        • Raw Chocolate
        • Raw Chocolate Brownies
        • Raw Coconut and Sultana Brownies
        • Raw Energy Balls
        • Raw Ice Cream
        • Raw Raspberry Cheesecake
        • Raw Rolos
        • Raw Snickers Joy
        • Rocky Road Raw Vegan Style
        • Salted Caramel Almond Nice Cream
        • Summer Fruit Nice Cream with Mango Sorbet and Fruit Coulis
        • Super Cookies
        • Vegan chocolate chip cookies
      • Smoothies and Juices >
        • Banana Free Smoothies
        • Caramel chocolate smoothie
        • Juices
        • Smoothies (featuring the brilliant banana)
  • Me
    • As a Speaker
    • Leonie Dawson courses
    • Mindfulness >
      • My Children's Meditations
    • Links
  • Availability/Fees
  • Get in touch
  • Events
    • Introduction to Homeopathy
    • ARH Conference
    • Homeopathy Marathon
    • Shamanic Ceremony
    • Ceilidh at Christmas
    • Inspired by Homeopathy
    • Retreat
  • Blog
07734 861297

Thoughts on the world, homeopathy, mindfulness and food...

A collection of blog posts - feel free to respond with your thoughts and comments - I love to have feedback - thank you!

A recent chat part II

6/7/2018

0 Comments

 
So I didn't realise there'd be a sequel, but here you go. It seems everyone has an opinion on homeopathy these days, and my current issue is that I feel many of these opinions have come from mainstream media. Which is interesting as this doesn't reflect my experience at all. Which makes me question mainstream media. I mean, you can't see people in front of you getting better then get told what you do doesn't, can't work and not question this stuff. It just doesn't add up.

Anyway, after having some lovely feedback about about part I, here's part II. I think I'll draw the line here, there's sunshine to appreciate and life to live.

So this one went as follows:

Them (in response to news of the judicial review): This is great news, the last the NHS needs is to waste taxpayers money on treatments that have a discredited evidence base. Let's hope NHS funded hospital chaplains are next.

Me: Of course I’m unsurprised at your comment, given our recent fascinating exchange. Many patients, who came to homeopathy out of desperation, having been through specialist referral to other units but not found help there sadly are the ones that are affected, and often they can’t afford to pay privately. So patient suffering doesn’t equate to great news for me. In the Bristol homeopathic hospital study, out of 6,500 patients (involving 23,000 or so appts), 70% reported improvements in their health after using homeopathy. 

I hope the recent discrediting of paracetamol based drugs and antidepressants may make people look further at these, but following the line of money I should think they’re fairly safe for a long time to come. People are seeking out alternatives to heavy drug based medicine, and it’s a growing trend. My clients don’t find me because I’ve spent millions on marketing, they find me because someone tells them that they got better using homeopathy, so they come and give it a go. The stories I hear aren’t from people who are deluded, delusional or stupid. They are from people who have tried other options (mostly via our NHS), maybe that was in the form of steroids, anti anxiety meds, antibiotics, antidepressants, painkillers etc and these treatments haven’t made the problem go away. This is medicine that’s failing people. Why would you need a lifetime of painkillers if they worked?! Constant antibiotics and still getting UTIs? Antidepressants for many years? Steroid creams to keep applying? Antihistamines daily?! We have a big problem and homeopathy, unpopular as it may be in mainstream medicine, can offer some seriously life changing help for people. For many things there are no options conventionally - molluscum for example, and yet I’ve seen them go within four days of the appropriate remedy being given. It’s not easy work, people are individuals and must be treated as so to help them at a deep level. Forever grateful to be doing it though.

Them: 
Oh dear. I guess I can see why the decision the NHS made has upset you, as it removes the 'legitimacy' of homeopathy and places it squarely with the other practices that have been discredited. I don't suppose the NHS did this lightly, having promoted homeopathy for quite some time and we have a Health Secretary who is a believer. I am genuinely pleased that the individuals you work with are feeling well, but let's be clear : whatever is working for them, it's highly, highly unlikely that it's purely down to the fact that water has a 'memory' and all that jazz. I've lost count of the patients who have been started on an anti depressant one day and reported feeling cured the next. The difference is that we will explore the logical fallacy, not embrace it.

Me: 
Just to say it's really lovely having you interact on my page here ****. 
Not only because more people get to see the information I share but because it makes me look closer at what I do. I would be fascinated to hear your explanations on how plants experience the placebo effect. To date, no one has adequately explained how babies and animals get better (and why conventional medicine, with all it's Wizard of Oz the Dr is God thing going on didn't help them but their eczema cleared up, digestive symptoms went and stopped omitted every feed), but maybe after all I or the vet was more charismatic and the placebo effect passed on through us (I'm not known for self flattery though :-/and actually if this is so then this is a whole new phenomena we should be highly excited about investigating IMHO). But plants in a triple blind RCT? Love to hear how those researchers influence those little seedlings.

Them: 
Well, obviously, it's not the placebo effect (unless Prince Charles was right all along) but there are plenty of other candidates; confirmation bias, self fulfilling prophecy, regression to the mean, etc - or possibly nothing. This is similar to the 'god of gaps' argument; if it isn't A, and you can't immediately prove why, then it must be B. I think you're be a little disingenuous when you talk about 'a whole new phenomena'. Homeopathy has had over 220 years to find a repeatable, testable and creditable method of proving how it works and has so far failed to convince anyone other than other homeopaths, as the recent decision by the NHS underlines. The seemingly endless litany of anecdotes just isn't cutting it.

Me: 
I'm fully aware we may as well be speaking different languages, so I guess we are unlikely to ever agree, which is fine. Seeing something in practice time after time (and yet it should be impossible if as you say the science is right) does make me curi
ous though. Anecdotes may mean nothing to you but seeing my child recover from croup within 10 minutes from struggling to breathing normally is pretty remarkable to me. As a mother that meant a lot. Helping someone else's baby not need to be in hospital every month and no longer need antibiotics since they've been working with homeopathy? As a practitioner that'll do too.

As for 'homeopathy has had over 220 years etc' yes, I find that amazing too. Many of the remedies used then are still being used, and, for example belladonna in certain types of fever, pulsatilla for some ear infections where the symptoms fit. How many drugs have come and gone out of fashion over that time? And yet homeopathic medicines are still there. Interesting. Or maybe not to you. I think I mentioned before, following the funding for research, is useful to me. Many (sometimes overused) meds were researched by the companies who developed the drugs. So there's no bias there. And intriguingly how many of these drugs are then withdrawn. I also saw reference recently to that just 11% of over 3000 treatments evaluated have been proven to be beneficial. Commonly prescribed treatments. Not homeopathy. So I'm unsure too if there's a gold standard we're supposed to be aspiring to. My results certainly feel way better than that.

To conclude: If the information or studies referred to are use to you to forward, replicate, then do feel free. For many years I would be more concerned about people asking about homeopathy, or feel I had to defend it. I'm happy to say I've moved past that place and whilst I feel incredibly passionate about it, I am happy for people to have their own (sometimes very polarised opinions) and chat about my side of the argument. As the Five Agreements so wisely teaches us - be skeptical but learn to listen.

​With love, Em x
Picture
Be the light.
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    I'm a Homeopath working in the Skipton (North Yorkshire) area. I am also able to offer food intolerance testing using Kinesiology and advice around diet and lifestyle.
    My blog is a reflection of thoughts, collection of recipes, suggestions of self help remedies and more.

    Archives

    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    January 2020
    July 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013

    Categories

    All
    2014 Calendar
    Absolute Specialists
    Animals
    Apple
    Avocado
    Ayuvedic Medicine
    Banana
    Banana Free
    Bowen
    Breakfast
    Byron Katie
    Cancer
    Carrot
    Challenge
    Change
    Charity
    Chocolate
    Coconut Oil
    Dairy Free
    Dates
    Date Toffee
    Diabetes
    Diet
    Dynamis
    Epidemic
    Exercise
    Fish
    Focussed Mindfulness
    Food Production
    Food Production
    Forks Over Knives
    Gerson
    Green Smoothie
    Hayfever
    Headache
    Health
    Healthy
    Holiday
    Homeopathy
    Homeopathy For Health In Africa
    Homeopathy For Health In Africa
    Homeopathyhour
    Homeopathy Research
    Homeopathy Worked For Me
    Horse
    Ice Cream
    Ilkley
    International Diabetes Federation
    Juice
    Juicing
    Kale
    Kuvings Juicer
    Love
    Make A Difference
    Mango
    Migraine
    Milk
    Mindfulness
    Mouth
    Naked
    Neal Bernard
    Ngo
    Nutrition
    Oil Pulling
    Oral Hygiene
    Orange
    Peach
    Philips Juicer
    Pineapple
    Protein
    Pudding
    Raw Chocolate
    Raw Food
    Raw Food
    Raw Ice Cream
    Remedies
    Remedy
    Research
    Running
    Russell Brand
    Santa Fun Run
    Selfies
    Skipton
    Smoothie
    Spinach
    Strawberry
    Studio Pilates
    Studio Pilates
    Sundae
    Sustainability
    Talks
    Teeth
    The China Study
    The Snooks
    Treat
    Tumeric
    Vegan
    Vegan Smythe
    Vegetarian
    Water Fasting
    Water Fasting
    Watermelon
    Weight Gain
    Weight Loss
    Weight Loss
    World Aids Day
    World Diabetes Day
    Youtube

    RSS Feed

07734 861297   
em@emmacolley.co.uk


Em Colley MARH, Practitioner of Classical Homeopathy
BSc(Hons) Psychology and Neuroscience
Laughter Yoga Leader
Focussed Mindfulness Practitioner
Dip (SNHS) Kinesiology
Dip (SNHS) Holistic Nutrition
Certificate in Whole Food, Plant Based Nutrition
Picture
Picture
www.findahomeopath.org.uk
Member of the
Alliance of
Registered Homeopaths
  • Home
  • Homeopathy
    • Homeopathy - what can it treat?
    • The Homeopathic Consultation - what should I expect?
    • Testimonials
    • How to take a remedy
    • Homeopathy Awareness Week
    • Homeopathy and Wikipedia
  • Laughter Yoga
    • Laughter Yoga feedback
    • Laughter Yoga Sessions
    • Laughter Yoga Exercises
  • Supervision
  • Food
    • Food Intolerance Testing
    • Testimonials
    • Recipes >
      • Breakfast Ideas >
        • Banana Boats
        • Breakfast ice cream on fresh fruit
        • Granola
        • Smoothie bowl
        • Sunrise Smoothie Bowl
      • Dips, Dressings & Appetisers >
        • Carrot, Orange and Ginger Soup
        • Cheese-less cheese dip
        • Guacamole
        • Hummus (oil free)
        • Mango and Cucumber Dressing
        • Ranch Dressing
        • Seedy 'Slaw
        • Summer salad dressing
        • Wild Garlic Pesto
      • Mains >
        • Cashew Cheese-y Kale Salad
        • Creamy Avocado Noodles
        • Green Mango Soup
        • Lasagne. Scrummy, yummy, vegan lasagne.
        • Mango Spinach Salad
        • Middle Eastern Inspired Dinner
        • Moroccan Inspired Salad Dressing
        • Raw Coconut Curry with Cauliflower 'Rice'
        • Raw Curry
        • Simple, Tasty and Nutritious Romaine Wraps
        • Spiralised courgette, chopped tomatoes, celery, spring onion with an red pepper, garlic, lemon and cashew cream sauce
        • Squashy Mac n Cheese
        • Sundried Tomato Tart
        • Sweet Mango Noodles
        • Sweet and Sour Noodles
        • Sweet potato, chilli mixed veg with cauliflower and kale 'rice'
        • Vegan Carbonara with Vegetables
      • Desserts >
        • Almond butter and date toffee stacks
        • Anyone for (low fat, high carb, raw vegan) Blueberry Pie?
        • Apple and strawberry crumble with salted caramel nice cream
        • Banoffee Ice Cream Pie
        • Banoffee Pecan Pie
        • Birthday cake pie!
        • Carrot Cake Balls
        • Chocolate almond sundae
        • Chocolate and Peanut Butter Pudding
        • Chocolate Extravaganza Ice Cream
        • Chocolate Ginger Brownies
        • Chocolate Orange Cupcakes with Raw Chocolate Icing
        • Chocolate orange fudge
        • Christmas Energy Balls
        • Christmas pudding 'cheesecake'
        • Cinnamon, vanilla pud
        • Coconut Happy Bars
        • Ice Cream Cake
        • Lime Cheesecake
        • Mango and apple tart
        • Mango and Raspberry Tart
        • PBJ Ice Cream
        • Peanut Butter Banoffee Pots
        • Peanut Butter Bar
        • Pecan Date Bites
        • Plant power pancakes
        • Pumpkin Pie (raw vegan)
        • Raw Bilberry Pie
        • Raw Chocolate
        • Raw Chocolate Brownies
        • Raw Coconut and Sultana Brownies
        • Raw Energy Balls
        • Raw Ice Cream
        • Raw Raspberry Cheesecake
        • Raw Rolos
        • Raw Snickers Joy
        • Rocky Road Raw Vegan Style
        • Salted Caramel Almond Nice Cream
        • Summer Fruit Nice Cream with Mango Sorbet and Fruit Coulis
        • Super Cookies
        • Vegan chocolate chip cookies
      • Smoothies and Juices >
        • Banana Free Smoothies
        • Caramel chocolate smoothie
        • Juices
        • Smoothies (featuring the brilliant banana)
  • Me
    • As a Speaker
    • Leonie Dawson courses
    • Mindfulness >
      • My Children's Meditations
    • Links
  • Availability/Fees
  • Get in touch
  • Events
    • Introduction to Homeopathy
    • ARH Conference
    • Homeopathy Marathon
    • Shamanic Ceremony
    • Ceilidh at Christmas
    • Inspired by Homeopathy
    • Retreat
  • Blog